> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.castleandcloister.co.uk/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Can You Love an Artist and Hate Their Fans?
- URL: https://www.castleandcloister.co.uk/can-you-love-an-artist-and-hate-their-fans/
- Published: 2026-11-13T12:45:10.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-13T12:45:10.000Z
- Author: Tara King
- Tags: Arts, Culture, Perspectives

Can you love an artist and hate their fans? It seems a strange question to ask: how can the people who share your enthusiasm for an artist become the people who make that enthusiasm difficult to express? Yet, in some corners of Taylor Swift’s fandom, expressing reservations about a song can become a referendum on whether someone was ever a ‘real’ fan at all. Celebrating an artist’s work can become entangled with the expectation that every release must be revered.

This tension has been particularly illuminated by the release of *The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore*, which has revived much of the distaste and criticism of the original album. Now, I like these new songs; they’ve been on repeat for me since the deluxe album’s release. But enjoying them does not mean I consider them Taylor’s finest work, just as acknowledging their shortcomings doesn’t make me love her music any less.

While some of the criticism has been sweeping, with some on social media condemning these as ‘her worst songs ever’, there is room for genuine critique. I share some of the reservations about the songwriting and execution, particularly when comparing lyrics such as ‘he likes what he likes what he likes and he likes me’ with ‘You talked me under the table | Talking rings and talking cradles | I wish I could un-recall | How we almost had it all’. Yet, there are still moments in *The Encore* deserving of praise. ‘Babylon’, in particular, echoes the evocative storytelling and emotional lyricism I love in *folklore* and *evermore*. We can appreciate the new songs for what they offer without insisting they are all masterpieces.

And therein lies the problem. Some ardent Swifties have responded to such reservations by dismissing those who offer them as ‘not real Swifties’. The question is suddenly no longer whether a song succeeds, but whether the person criticising it deserves to call themselves a fan at all. This shifts the focus away from the music to the presumed motives of the listener. In a Reddit thread discussing *The Encore*, one commenter suggested that ‘if we weren’t riding this huge Taynegativity wave from TLOAS \[*The Life of a Showgirl*\], people would be loving these new songs’. Another responded by insisting that ‘*I didn’t like encore because I didn’t like it*’. A similar frustration emerged in a TikTok discussion, where one commenter asked ‘is this a cult? Do I have to agree with you all that every song she ever releases is special and a unicorn and a masterpiece?’. This captures the exhaustion that can arise when enthusiasm starts to feel compulsory. There is a difference between celebrating an artist’s work and expecting every release to be met with unqualified praise.

Of course, there is nothing wrong with defending an artist or album you love, and some criticism deserves to be challenged, especially when it veers towards attacks on Taylor’s personal life. It is also easy to sympathise with the impulse to defend music that means a lot to you: if it has helped someone through a difficult period or become wrapped up in personal memories, another listener’s dislike might feel surprisingly personal. The problem arises when disagreement becomes delegitimisation, overriding healthy discussion. Expressing reservations about an album does not negate affection for the artist, just as loving a song unreservedly does not make someone undiscerning. We need to recognise that different fans connect with Taylor’s music for different reasons: some are drawn to her storytelling and esoteric lyricism, others prioritise the production, and some embrace the full range of her artistry. These preferences should be able to coexist without being arranged into a hierarchy of fan status.

This is not exclusive to Taylor Swift’s fandom, although it takes a different form elsewhere. For newly popular artists, gatekeeping often involves questioning the loyalty of fans who have only recently discovered their music. For example, Ashe has attracted new listeners through her hit ‘Stop the Wedding’, and her recent tour announcement has prompted some longstanding fans to question whether newer listeners are equally worthy of tickets. This ‘I was here first mentality’ establishes a hierarchy between established and newer fans, as though discovering an artist before their wider success makes someone a more deserving supporter. Surely, an artist gaining new listeners should be something to celebrate rather than resent. Enjoying an artist’s work is enough reason to secure tickets for their concert. After all, an artist’s music evolves, attracting new listeners at different stages of their career. Fans should not be made to feel imposter syndrome for more recently discovering a singer’s work.

Perhaps, then, the question is not so much whether we can love an artist and *hate* their fans, but whether we can find a comfortable space within a fandom without allowing its expectations to dictate how we enjoy an artist’s work.